Showing posts with label adolescent picture book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adolescent picture book. Show all posts

Sunday, February 20, 2011

THE WALL Growing Up Behind the Iron Curtain


Title: The Wall: Growing Up Behind the Iron Curtain


Author & Illustrator: Peter Sis


Genre: Children’s Picture Book, Nonfiction, Autobiography


Awards: Caldecott Medal (1997) & The Robert F. Sibert Medal (2008)


Media & Technique: Pen and Ink, colored pencil, & watercolor...Drawing, painting, and photography


Themes: History (historical event), Communism, Totalitarianism


Summary: This story is about a boy who grew up on the Communist side of the Iron Curtain. Through journal entries, captions, and the story of Sis as a boy, the story is an account of the Cold War era from 1948 to the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989.


Illustrations: This book is a bit like a graphic novel. the illustrations convey the tone through color. The sketches are black and white, with the only splashes of color being communist red and some color in the main character’s drawings. There are bright colors in one part of the book, demonstrating hope and cheerfulness; representing colors of freedom, but they go back to black and white to represent the totalitarian regime back in full force and the hope of freedom diminishing. The lines in the illustrations are thin. Sis uses a variety of lines though; horizontal, diagonal, vertical, curved, and thick. The black white and red throughout the book emphasized Communist colors, but red itself is a warm color. The illustrations are more cartoonish than realistic, with more organic shapes than geometric shapes. The text is placed all over the page, mostly following the flow of the illustrations. The design of the text is italicized at times to show its relation to the pictures, and when it’s not italicized it’s the story line. The texture of the pictures is visual, not tactile. The design of the illustrations is varied throughout the book. Some pages have one picture, while others have several pictures, in boxes. The pictures are mostly overlapping, although some have negative space for emphasis. There are several pages throughout the book that are journal entries. On these pages, the illustrations are the border around the journal entries. These include drawings and photographs. I think the photos emphasize that the journal entries were written by people; helps to match a face with text.


Literary elements: The setting of this book is in the past, during the cold war. It is set in Europe in the small country of Czechoslovakia. The place is real and intregal to the storyline since this is a historical event. It is depicted through the pictures. The author includes maps, as well as famous monuments in the illustrations. The characterization is not well developed and flat in the main storyline. He simply uses the main character (a young boy) to give the book a story line...BUT, in through the journal entries the character is very well developed and round. It’s like there are two separate stories in one. The journal entries telling the story of the boy and the storyline telling the story of that time period. The character goes through growth as he experiences the happenings around him during the Cold War. The plot is following a chronological order of events. The conflict is society versus the government control. The author explicitly states the theme, that the government takes away control of the people making everything compulsory and without opinions. The author believes that Communism is wrong and expresses in the text and through the pictures. The style of the book shows careful choice of words. The words printed at the bottom of each page make a statement, then the text lining the illustrations expands on that general statement with facts. For example, the text at the bottom of a page states, “Then he found out there were things he wasn’t told,” and the text aside the illustrations states, “Telephones are bugged. Western radio is banned. Certain book s and films are banned. Letters are opened and censored.” The author is explicit in stating that he felt the people were brainwashed. The story is written in third-person point of view.


Evaluation: I chose this book to share with older students because it’s 56 pages long, which is a bit long for a picture book. Also, it contains adult terms and information. It is nonfiction so it can easily be shared with middle and high school students who are studying the Cold War. I’m also intrigued by the text. There are journal entries, facts, and a story line all happening simultaneously. I like how the author uses the colors of the illustrations to connect to the text also.


Critical Literacy: This book touches on themes of freedom, self-expression, and government control. Students need to learn about ways in which they are unknowingly controlled at times, by the government or others. Students need to be made aware of the lack of freedom some have. This book encourages children to question what the information the government feeds them.