
Title: The Irish Cinderlad
Author: Shirley Climo
Illustrator: Loretta Krupinski
Media and Technique: Pastel colors, opaque watercolors, painting
Genre: Fantasy, animal fantasy, lighthearted fantasy
Summary: Becan, a poor boy belittled by his stepmother and stepsisters, rescues a princess in distress after meeting a magic bull.
Theme: The theme of the book is true love prevails. Good will always defeat evil, whether the evil lies in how family members treat each other or against creatures of mass destruction.
Illustrations: The illustrations are overly pretty and romanticized. When the text specifies a "blue-green sea," the picture shows a pinkish purple ocean. That doesn’t really fit. In a robust story of courage and danger, the dainty illustrations seem out of place. The illustrator uses lines to attempt to create texture within the illustrations. The lines are thin, both curved and wavy, as well as vertical and horizontal. A variety of color is used throughout the book. The color doesn’t seem to match the mood though. For example, when Becan fights the dragon the colors are bright and light, as though it’s a lighthearted happy page. The illustrator uses geometric shapes in the pictures, and they appear more cartoonish than life-like. This may be to appeal to children. The layout is overlapping and of relative size. Some of the illustrations break out of the page and into the text that is embedded, with leaves overhanging the text box, etc.
Style: The author carefully chooses words. It’s apparent that she has a point of wanting to make sure the story comes across as Irish. She includes Irish words and their definitions. The point of view is third person. The narrator conveys the story, as well as Becan’s feelings at times.
Genre Analysis: This story is a fantasy story because it involves a talking magic bull and a fir breathing dragon. Neither of these creatures exist in the real world. They are completely imaginary. In addition, there is a giant, and although there are big men in the world, there are not any giants. The evil characters are defeated and good triumphs. The hero (Becan) seems to be searching for something throughout the story, he travels along until the end of the book when he finds love.
Literary Elements: The setting is briefly stated - in Ireland and the past, ‘old times.’ The setting includes real places, Ireland, forest, meadow, orchard, cliff, castle, and beach. The setting is just a backdrop to the story...Becan could have been anywhere and the plot would not have been affected much. Becan’s character is the only one not flat. His growth is shown throughout the book. The characters appear young and child-like, which makes it easy for readers to identify with them. Becan has trouble getting along with his siblings, his feet are too big, he’s short, etc. Reader’s can identify with Becan, as being imperfect and only human. The plot is progressive. One thing happens after another, leading up to the happy ending. The hero (Becan) resolves all problems, mostly through the use of the bull’s magic tail. The conflict that Becan faces is self versus others...the others are his step family, a giant, and a dragon.
Personal Reaction: I enjoy this book because I’m drawn to stories that are twists on other stories. I grew up loving Cinderella and am intrigued by different versions. I also have a fondness for Ireland, so an Irish female author also caught my eye. This is not the first book this semester I’ve critiqued that was written by an Irish female...I wonder if I’m seeing a pattern. :)
Critical Literacy: The story seems to break the mold of the average ‘Cinderella’ story. This is about a boy who is an outcast in the family. After reading on, though, I realized that this book does contain stereotypes. Firstly, the boy rescues a princess that’s tied up and being sacrificed to a dragon. The boy defeats the dragon to save her and marries her in the end. Too predictable, especially with the man rescuing and the woman in distress, the evil stepsisters and stepmother, and the birth mother dies early in the story. One thing out of the norm is that the hero is a peddler, poor boy, not the King’s son. He’s also ridiculed for his appearance, going to show that the handsome one doesn’t always save the day and get the girl. The book includes Irish culture, mentioning Irish words and their meanings.







