Sunday, March 6, 2011

Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters



Sunday, March 6, 2011


Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters 

Title: Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters
Author/Illustrator: John Steptoe
Medium:  Textured Oil painting
Genre: Traditional Folklore/Fairy-tale
Summary: One day the Great King announces that he will seek a bride from among the women of the land. The arrogant Manyara and the the sweet Nyasha are two sisters whose father sends them to the city in order to go before the king. Pride will be punished and humility rewarded in this African version of the "Cinderella" story.
Awards:
Caldecott Honor Book
Coretta Scott King Award (Illustrator)
Reading Rainbow Book
Boston Globe–Horn Book Award
ALA Notable Children’s Book
Horn Book Fanfare
Parents' Choice Silver Honor

Illustration: This book won a lot of awards, many of them for the illustrations. Using a textured oil painting technique, the author/illustrator is able to render a very unique and exotic version of this African fairy-tale. While the story contains magic and talking animals, the illustrator was still able to make ever picture life-like and believable. African clothing, culture, plants, and  living conditions are all artfully portrayed. The illustrations in this book are timeless and can be related to any time period by readers...it could have happened a thuosand years ago, or a few years ago. What is important is that the pictures are an integral part of this story's unique interpretation.
Theme: The theme of this story is "kindness and goodness will triumph over selfishness and greed".

Genre Analysis: This is an African version of the traditional "Cinderella Story". The story fits the traditional folklore/fairy-tale genre perfectly: good overcomes evil, "positive" character traits are rewarded while "negative" traits are punished, there is magic, a traditional moral is reinforced, and the "good girl" becomes a queen.
Literary Elements: The setting of the story is integral to the story itself. The author periodically makes references to traditional African customs, beliefs, and culture that would lose meaning if taken outside of a traditional African setting.
    The author's use of prose to relay the story is also important for setting a "fairy-tale mood" for the actions taking place. No exact time is given, the story takes place "a long time ago". No exact details as to the village are set-up, besides it was "in a certain place in Africa." By making the exact detail of the story so blurry, the author reinforces the "fairy-tale" belief that the story may have happened a long, long time ago...or maybe very recently...and it may have taken place in a far away village...or in our very own village. That kind of reinforcement is necessary for readers to feel that the story could be about ANYONE.
    I don't believe the characters in this story were very "round'. The author intentionally has the story narrated from a "neutral" third-person point-of-view that allows the reader to judge the merits of each character based on their actions. (With a little "help" from a slightly slanted "neutral" narrator.)
Critical Literacy: This book is listed as appropriate for K-12, but older children will benefit more. Young children will be entertained, fascinated by the artwork, different way of life, and from the parallels with the European version of "Cinderella", while older children will benefit from the advanced vocabulary, in-depth exposure to another culture, and the history of traditional literature. The universal theme of good vs evil can be found in every culture, so it is important to show how all mankind is the same, while at the same time examining their differences. 
    That being said, I think it is also important to point out the patriarchal pedagogy found within this story so that young girls do not fall victim to it. Yes Manyara is selfish, conniving, and an opportunist...but that does not make her "evil" and a character that should be disliked. (Maybe she just didn't like meeting strangers on the road and did not share her food because she was hungry.) Nyasha was sweet, thoughtful, friendly, hard-working, and giving...why does that automatically make her "good? I think it is very important that dialogue take place that evaluates where these stereotypical labels come from and the reason society is so quick to accept them. 

Evaluation: I think this would be a wonderful book to read alongside of other versions of "Cinderella" so that children could compare and contrast them. I also think this book, even more than other Cinderella-stories, gives educators a wonderful opportunity to discuss diversity, cultural differences, cultural similaries, and gender role stereotyping.

No comments:

Post a Comment