Sunday, February 27, 2011

The Boy Who Cried Fabulous




Title: The Boy Who Cried Fabulous

Author: Leslea Newman

Illustrator: Peter Ferguson

Genre: Children’s Picture Book (Realistic Fiction)

Awards: Seal of Approval, National Parenting Center, 2004
Booksense Pick of the List, Spring/Summer 2004


Themes: Gender identity, Perspective, Diversity

Media & Technique: Gouache

Summary: Roger is a boy who enjoys the world around him...finding everything to be "fabulous!" Unfortunately, his parents and teacher do not find his fascination with the world to be "fabulous" at all and try to force him into more "traditional" behavior.



Illustrations: The illustration by Peter Ferguson really help the story achieve a timeless quality. While the general feel of the illustrations have a 50's-ish quality becasuse of the clothes, cars, and colors, but they are in reality seen even today. It is amazing how the illustrator uses vivid color and classic lines to refer to that "idea" time period in American Culture the 1950's...back when firm gender roles were an important part of American society. The way the illustrations and text mesh make them inseperable.
 Literary elements: The book starts off with a horrible double entendre geared toward the gay audience:

                  "When Roger started out for school,
                  his mother set a simple rule.
                  She said,"Now Roger, you go straight-
                  straight to class, and don't be late.""
Whether this "inside joke" is merely a nod to her gay audience, or is indeed to confirm that Roger's parents wanted him to be heterosexual, it still is an very effective way to play with semantics in order to convey additional information to readers. This "subtext" about sexuality goes very well with the themes of diversity and flexibility with gender roles.
    It's very easy to overlook the fact that the author varies his rhyme scheme to show the varying emotions in the book. Parents, teachers, the narrator, and even Roger use rhyming couplets when communicating with one another or having "normal" dialogue. When Roger becomes obsessed with the things around him, in his excitment he switches to intermittent rhyme. (This shows that Roger is truly "different" than the people around him and has a unique point of view.)
    This book uses the 1950's, when gender roles here in America seemed written in concrete, as a backdrop for the story of a young boy fascinated by the world around him. By setting the book during the 50's, I feel that the author and illustrator have made it integral to the overall work. It is impossible to separate the stereotypical gender roles from the cultural identities we associate with the 1950's.
    While most of the characters are "flat" and reduced to a stereotype: the various people Roger meets that are not detailed, the oppressive teacher, the concerned parents...Roger himself does show some growth. (And it can be argued that the parent do too since they come to accept their son...though I am not sure that is enough to show "roundness" of character.)
    I thought the author's word choice was a bit humorous. Newman chooses stereotypical "gay words" for Roger to use. While the word choice of the book will definately expand reader's vocabulary by introducing new or under-exposed words, I feel the words Roger uses themselves become a metaphor for being gay. Roger's parents try very hard to prevent or deny that their son is "different", but in the end except that Roger is "fabulous" the way he is.
Evaluation:  Once I started reading "The Boy Who Cried Fabulous", I found myself reading sections over and over trying to decipher all the deeper meanings in the text and illustration. While the story is certainly appropriate for children ages 5-12, there is enough information/subtext crammed into that book to keep older readers busy also...especially if older children are "guided" to some of the different ways this books various meanings could be applied. 

Critical Literacy: Okay, readers are never told that Roger is gay...so maybe some of us read more into the book than is actually there, but there is a reason the author won a LGBT award. This book touches on themes relating to gender roles, the importance of family, the search for freedom, self-expression, discovering the world around you, and maybe LGBT issues . Honestly, this book has as many meanings as people want to get out of it. While I love the vocabulary, the message, and many of the inside jokes...from a gay point-of view, the book itself is a little oppressive for me because it reinforces many of the age-old stereotypes about "gay behavior". (But if you use the book to POINT OUT/DISCUSS stereotypes, then it becomes a much more  effective tool.)

No comments:

Post a Comment