
Title: Stone Soup
Author: Ann McGovern
Illustrator: Winslow Pinney Pels
Medium: Pastels/Coloring Pencils
Genre: Picture book, poetry, traditional literature
Summary: A wise but hungry young man meets with a greedy lady and he says her that he can make soup from a stone, but he keeps telling her it would taste better with ingredients she has in her garden or around the house. Finally, he gets a full belly and takes his stone to fool the next person along his journey.
Other Relevant Information: This book is a well-known book. Many schools use this book to teach moral lessons to young children. In 2010, its 42nd birthday was celebrated in many schools in the United States. Moreover, this book was selected one of the 100 Best books for young children from the America’s Promise Alliance.
Art: The illustrations are drawn by pastels and coloring pencils. The pictures’ quality is fine, lines are clear drawn, textures are appropriate, but the colors are not bright. The main color of all the pictures is shaded, clouded, and vague. I think that the pictures are drawn long time ago and it might be reprinted many times so the colors might be faded. However, all pictures are well organized, so they are able to be complement, extend, and develop either each related text or the whole story. The illustrations are able to demonstrate, convey, stimulate, and make sense the poetic and fantasy tale through aesthetic appropriate way. For example, the old little lady’s clothing style looks like unusual. Therefore, it could indicate fairy imaginations. Also, the clever young man is drawn in some pictures as a joker and in some pictures he looks like in a meditative mood. These pictures of course could indicate how the man could fool the poor little lady.
Theme: I think that the author might wanted to let young children know about moral issues, life’s typical needs, and Mexican cooking technology, ingredients, and healthy foods.
Style: Fantasy, moral, informative, scientific, glorious, rhythmical, musical, and funny.
Genre Analysis: This story is a poetical folklore that written in a rhythmical, metered, and musical poetry. It is written in child-appropriate language so young children aged between 3 and 7, are able to understand. However, they may take adults’ support. It depends on their reading abilities or level. This poem is a funny, emotional, and laughable story so children will enjoy and learn to read following rhythms. I think that the poetry is able to create images of all sight, touch, smell, and taste because the author wrote it showing the technologies of cook very clear through step by step. Also, each illustration matches its text and this combination could make deep feeling. I am not sure how this poem sounds like because I never heard English. Anyway, I think that this poem used some forms of poetry such as, rhythm as word order, narrative, lyric etc. So when this poem is read it might sound like music. Therefore, it would grab children’s attention quickly. Everyone knows that songs and verses are easily to be memorized than prose. So this rhythmical peom might remain children’s brain and the children may try to imitate in their talking.
Literary Elements: This book is a fiction book, the events and settings occur in the past time and the story is a backdrop story. However, the place of this story can be integral because both the explanation and demonstrations such as, the house, garden, households, and fence look like real. The length of the description is a bit longer. However, it is a poem so it could be quickly read through rhythm. Therefore, children would not be bored yet they might repeat each page’s poem. There are just two characters, who cook together. I think, both the characters are well developed and/or round because although, their behaviors, personalities, and attitudes are not described clearly in words, through the occasion of the story children will be able to identify each character’s nature. The illustrations can help children to identify each character as well. The plot of this story is very clear, excited, progressive, and interesting. The problem appeared in the beginning, and solving process occurs in the middle, and finally the story ends with a positive and clever result. The whole story is well arranged, it is written child-appropriate language, and all illustrations are well matched with the text.
Evaluation: As I know this book is for young children between the age of 3 and 7. However, I wonder if young children could read such long and wordy poem (total 32 sheets). I think that this book is good for young children to learn how to cook and what ingredients would make a tasteful soup. However, one thing seems strange or danger. When the young man asked some beef bones, the little old lady took beef bones from her dog house. Then, a child may think that dog meals could be human’s food as well. Of course, a dog meal might lead people to sick. Finally, I was surprised when I know that this book does not have a single award because I found out that this book is a well written, beautifully illustrated, and well known book.
Critical Literacy: I think that this book reveals that life is not easy and there are plenty of problems and solutions. It would teach students if they try to have something, they would have this from nothing by using their intelligence. Also, this book allows students to understand aesthetics of language. I think that read aloud is better that independent reading because young children may not experienced how to read rhythmically poems so if they try read independently this book may seem burdensome.
No comments:
Post a Comment