Author: Marcus Ewert
Illustrator: Rex Ray
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Awards: 2008 Lambda Literary Award, 2009 Rainbow List Book, Honor Book, 2010 Stonewall Children’s and Young Adult Literature Award.
Summary: A young boy named Bailey wants wear the beautiful dresses he dreams about. Told that dresses are only for girls, Bailey longs to become the girl (s)he is inside.
Illustrations: The illustrations are rather cartoonish and slightly garish. While the dresses from Bailey’s dreams make for some beautiful illustrations, the artwork itself is minimalistic and rather simple. The redeeming grace of the artwork is the wonderful use of bright colors and the aesthetic pleasure that is gained from admiring the dresses themselves. The most interesting part of the illustrations is when it comes to the reader's perspective. The first image we have of Mother is basically through her eyes; she is cutting coupons in the kitchen and looking at Bailey. The mother’s point-of-view is the same as the reader’s. This point-of-view also takes place when Bailey approaches his father and the reader is presented from the father’s viewpoint. Most interestingly is when Bailey approaches his brother and the reader sees how small Bailey is in relation to his older brother, who legs are all we see.
Literary elements: Outside of Bailey, the characters in the book are flat. Bailey is given some roundness by means of the connection readers will feel as they read about the longing (s)he feels to become the person of his/her dreams. While the background of the story is merely a backdrop that adds little to the book itself, the other people Bailey encounters are integral to the plot. Bailey attempts to explain his/her dream to his/her mother, father, and brother…only to face rejection. Until finally Bailey makes a friend who will accept HER for who SHE is inside! To me, Bailey’s dreams and the people in Bailey’s life are the real background for the story itself.
The author is VERY flexible with his use of pronouns. While playing with the rules of language to deal with such a complicated subject is wonderfully artistic, and a more accurate portrayal of who Bailey is, than the rigid social and grammatical constraints of the English language…it is a difficult hurdle for “less progressive” minds to ponder.
Critical Literacy: While the author of “10,000 Dresses” never clarifies as to whether the book deals with transgendered children or with transvestitism, it does address the stereotype of gender roles. Unless you know what to expect, the book can be a bit confusing. Bailey is boy and dreams about dresses, but soon the book begins switching back and forth between masculine and feminine pronouns…referring to Bailey as “he” one minute and “she another. Children will need a fair amount of guidance trying to figure out when a boy is not a girl, but is a girl, but “supposed” to be a boy.
Evaluation: I enjoyed the book immensely, but feel that teachers will have to be VERY careful presenting it. Besides the protests of conservative parents, teachers will also face some difficulty explaining the author’s use of pronouns and answering the inevitable questions about transgender/transsexual issues. (All of which can be almost as confusing for adults as it can for children.)

No comments:
Post a Comment