Sunday, March 27, 2011

8 Ways to be Deaf


Title: 8 Ways to Be Deaf


Author & Illustrator: Adrean Clark

Genre: Realistic Fiction


Genre Analysis: The story could happen. The characters and events are fictional, but based on something that could or may have happened.


Media & Technique: Cartooning (graphic novel), computer art


Themes: Stereotypes (making assumptions about others), Perseverance (stick it out and in the end you’ll be rewarded)


Summary: A gas-station attendant, Paul, meets the girl of his dreams - but she’s deaf, and he’s his own worst enemy. Paul attempts to win her over, but after several failed attempts the girl moves away. Years later they cross paths again...will he win her over this time?

Illustrations: The illustrations are cartoonish. They are set up like a comic, in graphic novel format. The lines are thick, making the illustrations obviously cartoony and not life like. The illustrations also include a great deal of wavy lines to show the hands are moving...this is key to the story since the characters are supposed to be signing...the illustrator tries to show movement through line. There is a point when the illustrator uses squiggly scribbled lines to show that the movement is so fast that Paul doesn’t understand the signing. This meshes well with the storyline. The forms are geometric, also adding to the cartoonish appearance. The illustrator includes a variety of colors in the photos. The texture is flat, it doesn’t look at all like it could be touched, so it’s visual. The design of the illustrations includes a great deal of negative space.


Literary elements: The characters in the book are pretty flat. The main character, Paul, is somewhat round because the reader knows he’s interested in Linda, yet we don’t know too much about him. He’s white, mid twenties and works at a gas station. We know he tries to win over a girl, but because the dialogue is so limited we only get short phrases out of him. The plot is progressive. It starts with him meeting Linda, then everything he does to try to win her over, then him seeing her two years later after all his hard work. There is excitement and tension, because we’re curious if he’ll succeed. The setting is at a gas station, where Paul works and LInda gets coffee from regularly. The setting is just a backdrop, not integral to the story. Paul could have met Linda anywhere really. The time is also unknown, though it’s probably in the recent past because the illustrations show the gas price as $2.87, which is within the last five years, but not current. The style of the book is comic book like. This seems to be like a graphic novel. The story is mostly dialogue. The tone is humorous. Paul does silly things to try to win over Linda.


Critical Literacy: This book addresses the stereotypes that hearing people have about deaf people. The guy thinks of the ‘I love you’ sign and miming when he thinks of how to impress the girl who is deaf. The author tries to bring out the humor in this. Even though the author herself is deaf, I did have a few issues with the book. Firstly, the guy goes to an audiologist that calls deaf/ hh people hearing impaired. That seems like an old term to still be using. Also, the main character knows little to nothing about deaf people yet he says he wants to take an ASL class. In my own experience I’ve never met anyone outside of Gallaudet that calls it ASL; it’s always referred to as sign language. So, in that sense I feel like the author is giving the hearing guy too much credit. The professor of the ASL class is stereotypical as well. She’s an older lady with grey hair and glasses. This is exactly what people think of when they think of teachers, yet today teachers are mostly young and there are more men in the field now as well. In my experience I’ve had four male ASL teachers, never a woman, so this doesn’t fit what I feel to be the norm at all. Also, the main character’s fingers get tired from signing so much, which seems absurd. I do like how the author included a little bit of deaf culture, such as discussing DST and showing hugs as a greeting and departure routine. In general the author seems to try to include diversity through the characters. There are male and female, young and old, and races represented include white, black, and Indian. Lastly, the characters clothing seems to match the general rules of dark clothing for light skinned people and light clothing for dark skinned people; as well as solid colors, no prints.


Evaluation: I chose this book because it was a book about deaf people, written by a deaf person. When a book is written from experience, it seems better to me than by someone who just researches and then tries to write form another perspective. This book was also humorous which drew my attention. I’m more into graphic novels than ever before. When I was young there were only comics. Now graphic novels are getting the credit they deserve. They are good books with great info they can be great for struggling readers who need picture support. These are one type of book I want in my future classroom.

No comments:

Post a Comment