Sunday, March 20, 2011

The Spider and the Fly



Astro Bunnies

 

Astro Bunnies 

Title: Astro Bunnies
 
Author: Christine Loomis
 
Illustrator: Ora Eitan
 
Medium:  Gouache and Computer Techniques
 
Genre: Science Fiction/ ModernFantasy
 
Summary: Astro bunnies sit in their windows yearning to explore the universe. Through imagination they are able to soar throughout the Milky Way exploring the uncharted reaches of space...but always end their adventures where the are happiest, at home. 
 
Awards: 
Unicorn Honor Book

Illustration: Gouache is an ancient and versatile painting medium that the illustrator very creatively combines with computer graphics to make very unique illustrations for her book. The pictures were computer generated, then broad swatches of color were added to add depth to the pictures and to make them more interesting to the reader. All of the illustrations are very minimalistic and have a 50's-ish feel to them, making them rather timeless. 
Theme: With your imagination you can travel the universe...but "Rockets fly and/Rockets roam/But bunnies ALWAYS/Come back home."

Genre Analysis: Astro Bunnies is an excellent example of light-hearted Science Fiction/Modern Fantasy for young children. Asto Bunnies takes place in an alternate universe where "Astro Bunnies" take the place of human beings, specifically children themselves. Much like the children of our world, Astro Bunnies look out at the stars dreaming of other worlds...worlds they soon explore through their imagination. The author refers to real scientific equipments, planets, solar systems, and celestrial bodies in her work; but then have the bunnies interacting with it.

 
Literary Elements: The setting of the story is integral to the story itself. Astro Bunnies couldn't be "Astro" if they were not exploring space. The characters of this book are very flat, but easy for young readers to relate to; young bunnies longing to travel the stars. The author periodically makes references to rocket ships, spacesuits, real planets, the Milky Way, and to other elements from the real universe in order to make this book more realistic for young readers. The illustrations and the poetry themselves are inseparable. Set to the same rhyme scheme as "Twinkle-Twinkle Little Star", Astro Bunnies will feel familiar to children while at the same time introducing them to new vocabulary and ideas.
 
Critical Literacy: This book is listed as appropriate for pre-K through 3rd grade, with older children being a bit bored. Young children will be entertained, fascinated by the artwork, the idea of exploring space, and the parallels with our own universe. While young children will love the illustrations and familiar rhyme scheme, (The rhyme scheme is set to "Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star"), older children will be bored, but will benefit from the advanced vocabulary and introduction to science/space exploration. 
    That being said, while this book is supremely simplistic, it is a welcome addition to any library because it avoids any kind of gender roles or stereotypes. Curiosity is encouraged, as well as a love of home. 

Evaluation: This is a cute a book that will enjoyed by young readers. While I believe the vocabulary to be a bit advanced for the age groups it is intended for, the simplistic rhyme scheme and the minimalistic illustrations make it a timeless work that will encourage curiosity in children...while assuring them that home will always await.

Zathura


Title: Zathura

Author & Illustrator: Chris Van Allsburg

Medium: high textured paper, black and white stippling like the noise of a TV the far-away bits and pieces.

Genre: Science Fiction/ Modern Fantasy

Theme: sibling rivalry, space

Summary: Two energetic brothers find more excitement by playing with the board game. The game, "Zathura", board sends them and the house into space. They are in for the ride of their lives. This game comes to life each time they roll dice. The brothers have to work together to end the game. It's almost similar to Jumanji.

Illustration: The author tends to use black pencil. I guess his pencil drawings encourage children to connect their imagination and create a little bit of the world of themselves. His illustration is like black and white stippling like the noise of a TV. His illustration seems to show perspective, light and point of view.

Genre Analysis: Two energetic or quarrelsome brothers found the game and they come into space. Creatures and things from inside of the game, became real. They started to work as a team. They were seeking for a mysterious solution by figuring how to end the mystical space adventure board game.

Literary Elements: The setting of the story is integral to the story itself because it does specify particular time and taken into space, it might happen in space. Two main characters, two brothers, Danny and Walter Budwing don't get along and they get into small arguments. I guess their characters are kind of flat or whatnot because they show how they react or feel by looking at their facial expressions. In some ways, it shows their facial expressions and actions. The story started to notice Walter's feelings for his little brother are greatly changed. The plot of this story is progressive showing events that happen when each time they roll dice and things come to life from the game. It takes them into space . His writing style is the pencil drawings to encourage children to connect their imagination and create a little bit of the world of themselves. His illustration is like black and white stippling like the noise of a TV. They use of strong lines, shapes, black bold color to reveal the mood and tone of the story. The theme shows that Zathura set free intergalactic challenges that make those brothers to work as a team.

Cultural Diversity Analysis: Diverse culture were not represented, typical white siblings were struggling and getting along as a team into space. Walter has to help his sibling rival to get home. They can able to finish the game after they get along again.

Evaluation: This seems a wonderful story for children and slows children who have siblings, who may not always get long with them. They can find it easier to get along with their siblings when faced with a problem. I am sure children will understand how they are changed by the difficult experience that they go through together. To apply to them, they can be aware how they can learn to work together by solving problem and then they can enjoy each other's company.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

My Friend Rabbit

Title: My Friend Rabbit
Author/Illustrator: Eric Rohmann
Medium: Watercolor, print technique.
Genre: Modern fantasy, lighthearted fantasy, animal fantasy
Awards: The Caldecott medal 2003

Summary: The rabbit plays with brand new airplane with the mouse, which the airplane ends up in a tree. Rabbit develops an idea that he tells the mouse not to worry. He tries his best but his ideas always mean trouble. He creates a ‘ladder’ of animals such as an elephant, a hippo, an antelope, a crocodile, a bear, a goose, a squirrel, and climbs with the mouse to get the plane and then they all fall down. All the animals get upset with the rabbit because of his idea. The mouse flies down and rescues the rabbit from the animals in return for all the trouble to get the plane. The rabbit hugs and cause another problem – they crash into another plane. The rabbit comes up with another idea which means trouble again.

Illustration: The book won a lot of illustrations because the illustrations are simple and clear within the contexts. This is from print techniques and watercolor. The illustrator used core colors, hand colored relief prints for a heartfelt tale about being there for each other regardless if trouble follows. The pictures are an integral part of this story’s unique interpretation in animal fantasy.

Genre Analysis: This is comedy, action/adventure, and cartoon. The genre is fantasy, and the storyline is North American format. It creates a measurement of animal fantasies. The story is good in how people think in ways to solve a problem. For example, the readers who are around the age of 4 to 8 year olds can relate with the rabbit, will recognize this story about toys and getting in trouble and forming strong friendships to measure the environment compared with this animal fantasy.

Literary Elements: The literary style is short and parallel with the illustrations. The illustrations are clear and help the reader connect the text and the illustrations easily to understand the story. The point of view is a 3rd person point of view. The theme of this story is "to work together to solve problems." The main characters are the Rabbit and the Mouse. They work together and get help to retrieve his brand new airplane from the tree, also make a ‘ladder’ of animals which start with bigger animals at the bottom to the top smaller animals. This story does not have much of a plot and has minimal suspense because it does not tell what happens but only how to solve problems. The setting is integral in animal nature. The moral of the story focuses on friendship and solving problems.

Critical Literacy: This book is appropriate for children ages 4 to 8 because the use of text is straightforward with brilliant colors and expressive drawings. The illustrator wants to show the readers a tale of a quirky childhood friendship between the rabbit and the mouse, and also readers can more visualize the story and identify the variety of wildlife that the rabbit build the ‘animal ladder.’ The illustrator tries to help children read easy actually picture and understand the meaning of the story and may not be ready to read the words yet.

Evaluation: I think this would be a wonderful book to read and view pictures with more drawings and less words. For example, this picture show measure size of animals bigger and smaller which one the first and the end. They may understand without needing to point out which is bigger and smaller. I also think the children will enjoy the comically expressive pictures of the animals and discuss how to solve the problem of getting your brand new airplane.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

The Irish Cinderlad

Title: The Irish Cinderlad

Author: Shirley Climo

Illustrator: Loretta Krupinski

Media and Technique: Pastel colors, opaque watercolors, painting

Genre: Fantasy, animal fantasy, lighthearted fantasy

Summary: Becan, a poor boy belittled by his stepmother and stepsisters, rescues a princess in distress after meeting a magic bull.

Theme: The theme of the book is true love prevails. Good will always defeat evil, whether the evil lies in how family members treat each other or against creatures of mass destruction.

Illustrations: The illustrations are overly pretty and romanticized. When the text specifies a "blue-green sea," the picture shows a pinkish purple ocean. That doesn’t really fit. In a robust story of courage and danger, the dainty illustrations seem out of place. The illustrator uses lines to attempt to create texture within the illustrations. The lines are thin, both curved and wavy, as well as vertical and horizontal. A variety of color is used throughout the book. The color doesn’t seem to match the mood though. For example, when Becan fights the dragon the colors are bright and light, as though it’s a lighthearted happy page. The illustrator uses geometric shapes in the pictures, and they appear more cartoonish than life-like. This may be to appeal to children. The layout is overlapping and of relative size. Some of the illustrations break out of the page and into the text that is embedded, with leaves overhanging the text box, etc.

Style: The author carefully chooses words. It’s apparent that she has a point of wanting to make sure the story comes across as Irish. She includes Irish words and their definitions. The point of view is third person. The narrator conveys the story, as well as Becan’s feelings at times.

Genre Analysis: This story is a fantasy story because it involves a talking magic bull and a fir breathing dragon. Neither of these creatures exist in the real world. They are completely imaginary. In addition, there is a giant, and although there are big men in the world, there are not any giants. The evil characters are defeated and good triumphs. The hero (Becan) seems to be searching for something throughout the story, he travels along until the end of the book when he finds love.

Literary Elements: The setting is briefly stated - in Ireland and the past, ‘old times.’ The setting includes real places, Ireland, forest, meadow, orchard, cliff, castle, and beach. The setting is just a backdrop to the story...Becan could have been anywhere and the plot would not have been affected much. Becan’s character is the only one not flat. His growth is shown throughout the book. The characters appear young and child-like, which makes it easy for readers to identify with them. Becan has trouble getting along with his siblings, his feet are too big, he’s short, etc. Reader’s can identify with Becan, as being imperfect and only human. The plot is progressive. One thing happens after another, leading up to the happy ending. The hero (Becan) resolves all problems, mostly through the use of the bull’s magic tail. The conflict that Becan faces is self versus others...the others are his step family, a giant, and a dragon.

Personal Reaction: I enjoy this book because I’m drawn to stories that are twists on other stories. I grew up loving Cinderella and am intrigued by different versions. I also have a fondness for Ireland, so an Irish female author also caught my eye. This is not the first book this semester I’ve critiqued that was written by an Irish female...I wonder if I’m seeing a pattern. :)

Critical Literacy: The story seems to break the mold of the average ‘Cinderella’ story. This is about a boy who is an outcast in the family. After reading on, though, I realized that this book does contain stereotypes. Firstly, the boy rescues a princess that’s tied up and being sacrificed to a dragon. The boy defeats the dragon to save her and marries her in the end. Too predictable, especially with the man rescuing and the woman in distress, the evil stepsisters and stepmother, and the birth mother dies early in the story. One thing out of the norm is that the hero is a peddler, poor boy, not the King’s son. He’s also ridiculed for his appearance, going to show that the handsome one doesn’t always save the day and get the girl. The book includes Irish culture, mentioning Irish words and their meanings.

"The three pigs" by David Wiesner

Title: The three pigs

Author & illustrator: David Wiesner

Medium: Watercolor, gouache, colored inks, pencil, and colored pencil on Fabiano hot press paper.

Genre: Fantasy, modern fantasy, animal fantasy, lighthearted fantasy.

Summary: The three old pigs, which are the characters of an old story, magically went out of the wolf’s attack. Finally, they found their rescuer while they were wandering over a magical world, and lived happily ever after.

Other Relevant Information: This book won the Caldecott medal.

Illustration: The art work is created by various supplies such as watercolor, gouache, color inks, pencil, and colored pencil. The style of the illustration is colorful, clear, easy to understand, meaningful, creative, and used various drawing styles such as bold shapes, lines, and colors. For example, we can see both painted and line drawing pictures from the illustration. Drawing styles and the background styles are meaningful, attractive, and interesting.

Theme: I am not sure what the wanted to say. However, I personally think that this story can build children’s creative thinking, and might give the understanding of peace. Fighting is not a good way to have satisfied live, instead friendship, interactive through positive way, and understanding each other would give peaceful and satisfied life.

Style: The writing stile is lighthearted, creative, fantasy, repetitive but unpredictable, and progressive. The language is child-appropriate, short, understandable, build interestingly, and thoughtful. Typing style matches with the illustration style. For example, sometimes letters are not typed the standard line, instead they appear everywhere on the illustration. This makes the story and illustration interesting and impressive.

Genre Analysis: The main feature of this story is three pigs went out from the real setting to a fanciful and fantasy setting. For example, in the beginning, the three pigs live in a real world in their own built houses. Then a wolf ruins their houses and the three pigs blew out of the real world into fantasy setting. Both writing and illustration styles match its genre. From this, children would enjoy with the unusual, amazing, and fanciful structures.

Literary Elements: I personally think, that the author drew the illustration very careful because each detail of the settings, plot, and sequence are described very clear. For example, the story in an authentic setting and while plots process settings become artificial, unbelievable, and fantasy. However, the whole story is really integral. The settings are created very interesting. For example, real setting becomes a picture, pictures become fantasy setting, then fantasy setting becomes look like real. Time is not mentioned. However, this is a modern fantasy story, so the events and places are impossibility to happen. The main characters are the three pigs. They went away from the opposite character, wolf’s attack. The characters are flat, because each pig’s characterization, emotion, personality, and thoughts are not described at all. So these main characters would not be influential and inspiring into readers thoughts, mood and sense without the events. The three main characters are not well described but they are easily identified through the events and illustrations. The plot is progressive, well mannered, clear structured, interesting, problem solution, creative, and some events are repeated. The three pigs are sweet, kind, and cute. The helped others and the as a result they got their rescuer. At first, real problem is appeared that could happen in the word but the problem solved by incredible solution.

Evaluation: I think that this story shows some stereotypes such as good morals lead to happy life and bad morals will lose. As wolfs are mostly described as opposite character, in the story this stereotype is shown as well. The story generally seems that a modern version of the old, wide ranged tale of the three pigs, during the events other old, well-known stories’ characters are appeared. Therefore, I think that this story is a contemporary compound story of some old tales. In my opinion, this fantasy story would influence and develop children’s creative thoughts.

Critical Literacy: I noticed that the three pigs are drawn like three skin colors of people: white, black, and Asian. Their eyes are blue, brown, and green. From this, I guess the author might want to show anti-racism that we are all human and we do everything the same. However, reactions, thoughts depend on the reader’s age and understanding. I think that this book can be appropriate of all children. The illustrations are very well drawn so very young children can understand without reading the text as well.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Lon Po Po


Title: Lon Po Po

Author: Ed Young

Illustrator: Ed Young

Medium: Water Color, Colored pencil

Genre: Traditional Literature; Folklore; Beast Tales

Extra Information: The author, Ed Young won the Caldecott Award for this book. Not only did he won the Caldecott Award for this book but also he won two other Caldecott Honors for two books: The Emperor and the Kite and Seven Blind Mice. He was twice nominated for the Hans Christian Andersen Award.

Summary: The book of Lon Po Po is a China version of the Little Red Riding Hood story. To summarize the story, the books talks about three children staying home alone while their mother is off to see their grandmother. While the mother was gone, they have encountered the wolf that was disguised as an old woman.

Literacy Element: The setting is integral because it is important to know where the story is. So, the setting is in China and there are some places that show it in the book. The characters are Chinese people. The three children and the wolf are the main characters of the book. The wolf was the bad character and the older sibling was the brilliant ones. The plot is in order of events because it started off with a beginning with the mother leaving the children home going to the grandmother’s house. It gave a good start of the story and then to continue to the middle and the ending, it was not off the point. It got the story concept exciter and wanting to know what will happen next. The conflict of the story was person against person because the children did have a conflict with the wolf. As for the wolf, the conflict was person against society because of his passion was to get the nuts and his plan backfired. The point of the view was a third person because the narrator mentioned the texts. The style of the author was different than the other books I have read. The author’s word choices have fit the culture well by using words that was related to the Chinese’s culture. For example: “gingko nuts, hemp, awl, and Po Po.” The other word choice the author used was “Once, long ago” when most of the book will use the word choice of “Once upon a time.”

Illustration: The book had texts on every page and to some of the illustration they did not fit well. The illustration for me was not that great. The texts were, again a word choice that fit to the Chinese culture. For younger children, the illustration will not be great because the wolf looked scary. As for the older children, I think the illustration will be more appropriate because they understand the concept better than the younger children. The color is soft and not quite sharp. They were made with watercolor and colored pencils. The lines to the illustration are both thin and soft. Some of the lines are not really shown and some are. The drawings or pictures were organic shapes. Since the illustrations were soft, it was a free drawing and it was not even that close to any of the geometric shapes. The theme was always listen to an adult because if you don’t, something will happen. It is either that or do not talk to strangers.

Evaluation: The book was partly labeled as a stereotype because the wolf was always labeled as the bad, evil character. Not only it was based on the wolf but also the concept of good versus evil. Mostly the goods will win and the bad will lose. There was a lot of culture involved that help children understand the culture of Chinese better. The terms and settings were quite clear that they and I could see what they have out there that we do not have. The content of the book was quite in order that makes the audience curious what will have happened next. I like the book because I learned something from it even though it was a children book. The book will be something that I would read to the older children.

Cinderella


Title: Cinderella

Translator & Illustrator: Marica Brown but an original author is Charles Perrault

Medium: Pen and ink, line reproduction. Jacket-yellow-green and brown, halftone reproduction. Colored chalk. Gentle colors.

Genre: Traditional Literature; Folklore; Magic & Wonder Tales

Other Relevant Information: 1955 Caldecott Medal

Summary: This book is kind of French version by Charles Perrault, but Marica Brown freely translated. The story is about Cinderella kept serving her step-mother and 2 step-sisters even though she was mistreated by them. Later they left, fairy Godmother found her and got her to the Ball. She was thrilled and got a chance to see a handsome prince. At the end, a handsome prince tried to discover who was a beautiful princess... At the end, Cinderella won the heart of a handsome prince. She was grateful to have her fairy godmother.

Theme: things seem difficult, keep doing the right thing without complaining.

Literary Element: The setting is important because the readers can be aware how the story goes. The setting is a far away kindgom. The main characters are Cinderella and two evil step-sisters. Cinderella is a lovely, mistreated, a good girl. She never complained because she did her duty. The plot is in order of events because the story begins with what happens next about her life. She lost her father and happened to live with evil step-mother and two step-sisters. She was focused by doing many chores, but she wasn't complained. When word came of the prince's ball, she wasn't excited or aware if she can go. She just helped her step-sisters to get ready for the ball. The fairy godmother found her and made her into a beautiful princess. Her beauty dazzled everyone. She left to leave early because of midnight. Prince happened to find her glass slipper and wondered who was that girl. At the end, the slipper shoe belonged to Cinderella. They were shocked. Of course, they live happily ever after.

Illustration: I have never seen the kind of illustrations. The drawing was colored chalk, pen and ink lines. She illustrated Cinderella's soft and good character. She changed the color plot. She changed the color when she helped the readers to identify the step-sisters' cruel personalities, Cinderella's personality and the fairy godmother's features plus the story too. She also added thin lines like for an example, Cinderella's dress had a few lines dropping downward to demonstrate folds. That's why she won the award for her illustration.

Evaluation: I believe this book shows some stereotype because of stereotyped male sex role and stereotyped females sex role. Because of step-sisters will always be bad, evil character. In real life, they are not all bad. It depends on each individual. The story shows the concept of good versus bad or evil. The readers can understand how the story goes and entertain them. It is interested to see how her illustration with color softness to the tale and characters. They should see different kind of versions of Cinderella books.

Critical Literary: This book is listed as appropriate around the age 4 to 8. This book tell the tale in it simplest childlike form. I am sure the readers will feel entertained and fascinated by Marcia Brown's illustration and the tale.

Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters



Sunday, March 6, 2011


Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters 

Title: Mufaro's Beautiful Daughters
Author/Illustrator: John Steptoe
Medium:  Textured Oil painting
Genre: Traditional Folklore/Fairy-tale
Summary: One day the Great King announces that he will seek a bride from among the women of the land. The arrogant Manyara and the the sweet Nyasha are two sisters whose father sends them to the city in order to go before the king. Pride will be punished and humility rewarded in this African version of the "Cinderella" story.
Awards:
Caldecott Honor Book
Coretta Scott King Award (Illustrator)
Reading Rainbow Book
Boston Globe–Horn Book Award
ALA Notable Children’s Book
Horn Book Fanfare
Parents' Choice Silver Honor

Illustration: This book won a lot of awards, many of them for the illustrations. Using a textured oil painting technique, the author/illustrator is able to render a very unique and exotic version of this African fairy-tale. While the story contains magic and talking animals, the illustrator was still able to make ever picture life-like and believable. African clothing, culture, plants, and  living conditions are all artfully portrayed. The illustrations in this book are timeless and can be related to any time period by readers...it could have happened a thuosand years ago, or a few years ago. What is important is that the pictures are an integral part of this story's unique interpretation.
Theme: The theme of this story is "kindness and goodness will triumph over selfishness and greed".

Genre Analysis: This is an African version of the traditional "Cinderella Story". The story fits the traditional folklore/fairy-tale genre perfectly: good overcomes evil, "positive" character traits are rewarded while "negative" traits are punished, there is magic, a traditional moral is reinforced, and the "good girl" becomes a queen.
Literary Elements: The setting of the story is integral to the story itself. The author periodically makes references to traditional African customs, beliefs, and culture that would lose meaning if taken outside of a traditional African setting.
    The author's use of prose to relay the story is also important for setting a "fairy-tale mood" for the actions taking place. No exact time is given, the story takes place "a long time ago". No exact details as to the village are set-up, besides it was "in a certain place in Africa." By making the exact detail of the story so blurry, the author reinforces the "fairy-tale" belief that the story may have happened a long, long time ago...or maybe very recently...and it may have taken place in a far away village...or in our very own village. That kind of reinforcement is necessary for readers to feel that the story could be about ANYONE.
    I don't believe the characters in this story were very "round'. The author intentionally has the story narrated from a "neutral" third-person point-of-view that allows the reader to judge the merits of each character based on their actions. (With a little "help" from a slightly slanted "neutral" narrator.)
Critical Literacy: This book is listed as appropriate for K-12, but older children will benefit more. Young children will be entertained, fascinated by the artwork, different way of life, and from the parallels with the European version of "Cinderella", while older children will benefit from the advanced vocabulary, in-depth exposure to another culture, and the history of traditional literature. The universal theme of good vs evil can be found in every culture, so it is important to show how all mankind is the same, while at the same time examining their differences. 
    That being said, I think it is also important to point out the patriarchal pedagogy found within this story so that young girls do not fall victim to it. Yes Manyara is selfish, conniving, and an opportunist...but that does not make her "evil" and a character that should be disliked. (Maybe she just didn't like meeting strangers on the road and did not share her food because she was hungry.) Nyasha was sweet, thoughtful, friendly, hard-working, and giving...why does that automatically make her "good? I think it is very important that dialogue take place that evaluates where these stereotypical labels come from and the reason society is so quick to accept them. 

Evaluation: I think this would be a wonderful book to read alongside of other versions of "Cinderella" so that children could compare and contrast them. I also think this book, even more than other Cinderella-stories, gives educators a wonderful opportunity to discuss diversity, cultural differences, cultural similaries, and gender role stereotyping.

Hansel and Gretel

Title: Hansel and Gretel

Retold by: Rika Lesser

Illustrator: Paul O. Zelinsky

Medium: Oil painting

Genre: Picture book, traditional literature, fairy tale.

Summary: A mother pushed her husband to abandon their two children, Hansel and Gretel, in the forest because of their starving. Finally, the mother died and the two children back to home with plenty of treasures that could fed them with their father so they lived happily ever after.

Other Relevant Information: This book won Caldecott honor.

Illustration: According to the foreword of the book, the illustrator, Paul O. Zelinsky, is an ancestral illustrator. I think that he made very well illustration for the story. Especially, the characters’ facial expressions are able to convey each character’s internal thoughts, behavior, and moral. For example, the mother’s face, especially her eyes could indicate her selfish attitude and heartless soul. Whereas, I could see the kindness, regret, love but tired, exhausted sight from the woodcutter. Moreover, all pictures are colorful and drawn with every special detail. Especially, natural sight of the trees, sky, and cloud are beautifully drawn.

Theme: This is a fairy tale that has many alternatives. Although people’s perspectives might vary, I personally think that the content and result of the tale could impact human’s morality. Also, the unknown author of this tale, might want to say that adults not always smarter than children, instead we could see that even though children are innocent they are intelligent. Plus, we might think that being innocent is not meant of fool yet it could indicate good moral and intelligence. So, kind and warm-hearted people could receive god’s blessing.

Style: Fantasy, magical, moral, nurturance, regional, behavioral, traditional, cultural, and natural.

Genre Analysis: This book is a fairy tale and exactly fits with traditional literature genre. Whether the origin of the story is oral or written, we could imagine the setting and time could hardly to be defined because there are no time mentioned in the whole story. Also, there is no known author for this tale instead this tale is retold by many various authors and published and translated in many countries. I remember, this story has Mongolian translation. Also, traditional literature mostly includes one culture but we would hardly define an exact culture for the story. However, from the illustration: the clothes of the characters, the houses, house holdings, and the characters’ name, we might define that this tale is Europeans’.

Literary Elements: The setting is either can be integral or backdrop because without the old woman (witch) and her strange house, the events could be true. Plus the two children finally went back home without any magical way. Each setting is depicted in illustrations. Illustrations cover most space of the page, and every illustration has its text. The length of all text is not too long yet it could be child-appropriate. Moreover, the beautiful, clear, and text-appropriate illustrations are able to strength its following text and could help children to fully understand the whole story. The story has 5 characters. Each character is defined clearly so children could identify them easily. So I think that all the characters are round. Because each event helps children to build up each character’s attitude, behavior and identity. However, the parents’ identities are less described than the two children’s. The plot of both the text and illustration is visible, cumulative, and straightforward. The main problem is the mother’s plan to get rid of their children. Several subsequent problems occurred and those are solved by the children’s intelligence. I think that the plot is build very well because almost every purpose faces more than two problems and solutions. Therefore, it could teach children to think about problems for not give up for the first failure. Also, children might think that if they have good moral, they will have a satisfied lives. I think that the style of the writing is very well managed and build for young children because most of the text that follows an illustration, covers not more than four sentences. This limited length might help children to understand easily and not get bored. Also this story has rich vocabulary yet the complex words are not too many and they would not bother the children’s understanding.

Evaluation: According to the storyteller, Rika Lesser, “Hansel and Gretel” is originally an oral tale. So there are many alternative publications of this tale. However, according to Lisa Cobb “The original Hansel and Gretel are poor German children living with their evil stepmother and loving though henpecked father” (Cobb, 2004). From this, even though magical and unbelievable events occur during the story, it can be a real story. Therefore, the genre of the story might be historical fiction and biography. Moreover, the true story might be shrunk into child-appropriate length and language. I personally think that this story comes from real life. Anyway, this book might negatively impact children’s thinking about female. So adults and teachers need to support to better understand the intention of the story for children.

Critical Literacy: I think that this story is a universal fairy tale and might fit with 4-12 years old children, who could understand such stories that contain more than 4 events. As I mentioned in the evaluation about the negative impact of this story, teachers and adults need to navigate children for avoiding misunderstandings. Also, they might say about social justice, good moral, behavior, and challenges of life. It may depend on the children’s age and literacy level.

Title: Rumpelstiltskin

Author & Illustrator: Brothers Grimm (Collector) & Dennis Hockerman

Genre: Folktales, Fairy Tale

Theme: Greed and Power

Summary: A poor miller wanted to impress the king by telling him that his daughter had the special ability to turn straws into gold so the king told Miller to send his daughter over. The king asked Miller’s daughter to turn a room of straw into gold, but she did not know how to do so and that was when she gave up her necklace and ring for Rumpelsiltskin do turn the straw into gold for her. The third time she had to turn a room filled with straw into gold she had nothing to offer Rumpelstilskin, but her first newborn baby in the future.

Variants: This same story can be seen in various other cultures. It is known as Tom Tit Tot in England, Whuppity Stoorie in Scotland, Gilitrutt in Iceland, Joaidane in Arabic, Khlamushka (junker) in Russia, Pancimanci in Hungary, and Cvilidreta (whine Screamer) in Croatia. All of these stories are written in different language but have same story patterns.

Genre Analysis: This book is a collection of Bothers Grimm and the theme of the book includes greed and power. The theme of the book also concerns human beings such as the Miller and his daughter. The story is also told in a narrative form and the plot is clean and direct. For an instance, the queen sent a messenger to the woods to figure out Rumpelstiltskin’s name. There are some stereotypes in this book that includes the king telling the girl what to do before he can make her queen. The setting of the story is also very vague because it is obvious that it is at a kingdom somewhere, but where exactly it is unknown. This is known as a fairy tale because the story is magical with the straw to gold activity and with the troll who was considered as the strange looking man.

Personal Evaluation: I personally felt that this book was hard to follow at first because when the text would describe that the straws were being turned into gold, the illustration didn’t show that. Also, I feel like there was a lot of stereotypes regarding female versus male and social class too when Poor miller lied to the king about his daughter’s abilities so they could be rich.

Hansel and Gretel...Retold by Linda Hayward














The lion and The mouse

Title: The lion and the mouse
Author & Illustrator: Jerry Pinkney
Medium: Watercolor
Genre: Picture Book for Aesop’s fables
Theme: Wide horizon, abundant wildlife, and African Serengeti of Tanzania and Kenya.
Other Relevant Information: This book won the Caldecott Medal.
Summary: This book is a fable of Aesop about the lion and a mouse in African Serengeti of Tanzania and Kenya. The mouse happened to be on top of a lion in which the mouse got caught. The lion let the mouse go back to her family. Poachers left a trap in the jungle in where the lion got caught in. Then the mouse heard the lion in need for help and she came to his rescue. The mouse gnawed at the net to release the lion. The lion was very grateful toward the mouse. They became friends and parted their way.

Genre Analysis: This book has beautiful watercolor illustrations. The drawings of the story show us the moral of what you give is what you get. There are no unclear pictures. Reader should get a sense of what the illustrator is trying to express with this Aesop’s fable. It is a good interpretation of the lion and the mouse in Aesop’s story. The illustrator expose animals’ sense of freedom in the African Serengeti of Tanzania and Kenya and shows thus in a ‘wide horizon, and abundant wildlife.’ There are no words in this book except the animals’ sounds with their emotions portrayed as natural and as nature intended.

Art (Medium/Technique):
The illustrator mostly use watercolor and outline in this book. It makes the images clear as to show only the actions of the animals. This feels like 3D as if the pictures came from actual nature and animals.

Literary Elements: In this book, there are two main characters: the lion and the mouse. The mouse was portrayed as inferior and possibly a lunch for the lion because it is small. While the lion displays its bigness and cannot help that, but let the mouse go. The contrast between the lion and the mouse is obvious. The plot is in the wide horizon, abundant wildlife of African Serengeti of Tanzania and Kenya. The setting displays what freedom is like as animals living in Africa. It mostly uses episodic setting that each character involves with chronological order. It makes the readers figure out what next will happen between the lion and the mouse which they are different in size: small and big but can help the same way. Setting is integral with the display of who is big and who is small and it wouldn’t matter because both can help in their own way. Being big isn’t always better than being small because being small could have the ability to strategize wise. The book gives a good comparison which would help the readers understand the importance of different sizes may make things right in life. The theme in Aesop’s fable has a metaphor with sizes and resources that would help make the reader visualize the moral of the story. The illustrations are clear to help the readers imagine what is like to be an animal. The styles are without words but are brief with short animal sounds. Reader can relate the moral of the story to good duty toward others.

Critical Literacy: Author shows the illustrations of a lion and the mouse to help readers learn to compare and contrast the similarities and the differences of both animals. One who can help the other, no matter how big or small one is and it does not always have to be a big animal helping. Some people think that small animals cannot help others who are big because small is not strong, but they have other resources that big animals do not have such as the power to gnaw its way out and that concept applies to us, human people with our resources.

Personal Evaluation: This book is very great and I enjoyed the illustrations very much. It portrays 3D and beautiful artistic background in only yellow. The color yellow suits with the story of the animals and matches with the time frame emphasizing the daytime. The illustration is very clear and easy to follow with the pictures without the texts. The sounds of animals in words are short to read and natural to expect. The Aesop’s story is about that anyone no matter what size they are can help others.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Gracias / Thanks

Title: Gracias Thanks
Author: Pat More
Illustrator: John Parra
Genre: Poetry, Contemporary realistic fiction
Medium: Folk-art woodcuts, acrylic painting
Theme: Giving thanks
Other Relevant Information: Pura Belpré Honor Book
Summary: A young Hispanic boy gives many thanks for the specific things, event, and people everyday.
Genre Analysis: This author uses repetition to emphasize the young hispanic boy's feelings about thanks. The young Hispanic boy uses repetition to emphasize word, "thanks" or "gracias" when things enrich his life. It also has fresh imagery.
Art (Medium/Technique): John Parra illustrated this picture book so bright acrylic painting and represented the story about the Hispanic boy’s life. The author also added bilingual text: Spanish that appears on each left side, with the English on each right side.
Literary Elements: The characterization was family characters with Hispanic-american mother, father, and little siblings. Also, friends included in this story. The young boy has many things to do with his fun, family and friends. There is no negative because the author just wrote a happy family. The theme was all about giving thanks whenever it enrich to the young boy's life. The style of the story was repetition and imagery.
Critical Literary: I think children will enjoy and learn to understand how bilingual families do. Also, the author wants to send the reader some messages that they should be encouraged to give thanks. They can share large or small pleasures with people. It will be benefits for them to learn another language too.
Evaluation: I like this book because children will be interesting to see pictures with both texts; english and spanish. This book can be for young children from kindergarten to fourth grade. I think it helps children to learn how to give thanks everyday.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Barack Obama of Thee I Sing: A Letter to my Daughters


Title: Barack Obama of Thee I Sing: A Letter To My Daughters

Author: Alfred A. Knopf

Illustrator: Loren Long

Medium: Acrylic on board

Genre: Poetry; Biography

Summary: This book is age appropriated from the age four to eight. It is a letter for Obama’s daughters explaining about some of the specific famous people who all are related to the American history.

Literacy Element: The setting of the book is integral because for each American, it is important to know and see when and where their time was. Every person that was mentioned and honored in the book did not come from the same period of life. The places needs to be fitted to the character such as Jackie Robinson, he had fans behind him, which was a good illustration. The characters are neither round nor flat because it was just a letter to someone explaining the famous people that made changes in life. As I have read and known of, the story does not really have a plot because it is an explanation of each person. The conflicts of the people have a common conflict such as self versus society. It is most basically on society because of each period of time they have lived in have something that society did not accept until one of them made a change in the world. Point of view in the book is a first person when there is I’s used in the text. Third person could be because there was an explanation of each person by using he or she. The theme of the story is anyone can make changes in the world by doing something that will change in people’s life.

Illustration: The book had texts on every two pages yet the illustration does fit to the text greatly. The illustration is beautiful and it does fit to children’s imagination of the book. It is very clear for children to visually see what the person does that fits to the text as well. The illustration might not be used by a loud color but very soft and warm. The lines are slightly thin and have shadows to it, which makes the mood softer. The drawings or pictures are more of organic, free drawing not any closer to geometric shapes. In addition, I liked the part of a Sioux illustration because it is a picture of trees, animals, and grasses/dirt, which made a face of an Indian named “Sitting Bull.”

Evaluation: Not only the book shows the important historians in America, but also explaining the theme that we honor them for what they did to change the world. If there is something we want to change, we should go for it to make the world a better place. I like the book because it is a blended genre of poetry and biography. It relates to everything well such as history of people, literacy, learning how to respect others. Again, I liked the illustration because it has a soft moods and blend with the text well.

The Boy Who Cried Fabulous




Title: The Boy Who Cried Fabulous

Author: Leslea Newman

Illustrator: Peter Ferguson

Genre: Children’s Picture Book (Realistic Fiction)

Awards: Seal of Approval, National Parenting Center, 2004
Booksense Pick of the List, Spring/Summer 2004


Themes: Gender identity, Perspective, Diversity

Media & Technique: Gouache

Summary: Roger is a boy who enjoys the world around him...finding everything to be "fabulous!" Unfortunately, his parents and teacher do not find his fascination with the world to be "fabulous" at all and try to force him into more "traditional" behavior.



Illustrations: The illustration by Peter Ferguson really help the story achieve a timeless quality. While the general feel of the illustrations have a 50's-ish quality becasuse of the clothes, cars, and colors, but they are in reality seen even today. It is amazing how the illustrator uses vivid color and classic lines to refer to that "idea" time period in American Culture the 1950's...back when firm gender roles were an important part of American society. The way the illustrations and text mesh make them inseperable.
 Literary elements: The book starts off with a horrible double entendre geared toward the gay audience:

                  "When Roger started out for school,
                  his mother set a simple rule.
                  She said,"Now Roger, you go straight-
                  straight to class, and don't be late.""
Whether this "inside joke" is merely a nod to her gay audience, or is indeed to confirm that Roger's parents wanted him to be heterosexual, it still is an very effective way to play with semantics in order to convey additional information to readers. This "subtext" about sexuality goes very well with the themes of diversity and flexibility with gender roles.
    It's very easy to overlook the fact that the author varies his rhyme scheme to show the varying emotions in the book. Parents, teachers, the narrator, and even Roger use rhyming couplets when communicating with one another or having "normal" dialogue. When Roger becomes obsessed with the things around him, in his excitment he switches to intermittent rhyme. (This shows that Roger is truly "different" than the people around him and has a unique point of view.)
    This book uses the 1950's, when gender roles here in America seemed written in concrete, as a backdrop for the story of a young boy fascinated by the world around him. By setting the book during the 50's, I feel that the author and illustrator have made it integral to the overall work. It is impossible to separate the stereotypical gender roles from the cultural identities we associate with the 1950's.
    While most of the characters are "flat" and reduced to a stereotype: the various people Roger meets that are not detailed, the oppressive teacher, the concerned parents...Roger himself does show some growth. (And it can be argued that the parent do too since they come to accept their son...though I am not sure that is enough to show "roundness" of character.)
    I thought the author's word choice was a bit humorous. Newman chooses stereotypical "gay words" for Roger to use. While the word choice of the book will definately expand reader's vocabulary by introducing new or under-exposed words, I feel the words Roger uses themselves become a metaphor for being gay. Roger's parents try very hard to prevent or deny that their son is "different", but in the end except that Roger is "fabulous" the way he is.
Evaluation:  Once I started reading "The Boy Who Cried Fabulous", I found myself reading sections over and over trying to decipher all the deeper meanings in the text and illustration. While the story is certainly appropriate for children ages 5-12, there is enough information/subtext crammed into that book to keep older readers busy also...especially if older children are "guided" to some of the different ways this books various meanings could be applied. 

Critical Literacy: Okay, readers are never told that Roger is gay...so maybe some of us read more into the book than is actually there, but there is a reason the author won a LGBT award. This book touches on themes relating to gender roles, the importance of family, the search for freedom, self-expression, discovering the world around you, and maybe LGBT issues . Honestly, this book has as many meanings as people want to get out of it. While I love the vocabulary, the message, and many of the inside jokes...from a gay point-of view, the book itself is a little oppressive for me because it reinforces many of the age-old stereotypes about "gay behavior". (But if you use the book to POINT OUT/DISCUSS stereotypes, then it becomes a much more  effective tool.)